Supreme Court of India · [1978] 3 S.C.R. 509

Baigana And Ors. v. Deputy Collector Of Consolidation And Ors.

Decided
14 March 1978
Neutral citation
1978 INSC 68
Bench
V.R. KRISHNA IYER, JASWANT SINGH
Outcome
Dismissed
Cited by 3 later Supreme Court judgments

BAIGANA AND ORS. yy . DEPUTY COLLECTOR OF CONSOLIDATION AND ORS. March 14, 1978 {V. R. KrisuNa Iyer AND JASWANT SINGH, JJ.]

Constitution of India, 1950, Arf. 136 read with Order XVI Supreme Court Rules 1966,—Supreme Court cannot be converted into a court of fifth appeal.

Dismissing the special leave petition, the Court

HELD: The Supreme Court is more than a Court of appeal, it exercises power only when there is suprente need. Jt is not the fifth court of appeal but the final court of the nation, Therefore, even if legal flaws may be electronically detected, this Court cannot interfere sans manifest injustice os substantial ‘question of public imporiance. [509 Ej

Civit APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Special Leave Petition (Civil) No. 4963 of 1977.

(From the Judgment and Order dt. 21-9-75 of the Allahabad High Court in Writ Petition No. 92 of 1969)

S. N. Singh, for the petitioner. The Order of the Court was delivered by

KRISHNA IYER, J. The Supreme Court is more than a Court of appeal. It exercises power only when there is supreme necd. It is not the fifth court of appeal but the final court of the nation. Therefore, even if legal flaws may be electronically detected, we cannot interfere sans maniiest injustice or substantial question of public importance. By this token, the petitioner has missed the bus. Dismissed,

SR, , Petition dismissed,

15—2778C[78

Cited by · 3

Later Supreme Court judgments in our index that cite this one by name, newest first.

Found by matching case names, so a citation written very differently can be missed, and High Court judgments are not included. Read the citing judgment to see whether it followed or distinguished this one.

Text of the official Supreme Court Reports (S.C.R.) edition, extracted from the court’s PDF. Page headers and margin letters have been removed; a stray one may remain inside a paragraph. For citing, rely on the official PDF.

Source: Indian Supreme Court Judgments open dataset (CC-BY-4.0), from eCourts.